Josh Reynolds played nine TFL seasons across two separate stretches, appearing in Seasons 1–3 and Seasons 10–15. He played for the San Francisco Earthquakes, Alabama Razorbacks, New Jersey Wings, and Oregon Beavers.

Reynolds earned 1 Pro Bowl and 1 All-Pro selection during his career. His Pro Bowl came during his time with the San Francisco Earthquakes.

He scored 27 receiving touchdowns over his career, averaging 3.0 touchdowns per season. All 27 of his career touchdowns came as a receiver.

Reynolds’ teams finished .500 or better five times and made five playoff appearances. He later became an Oregon Beaver through the Season 14 Expansion Draft and spent his final two seasons with the franchise.